• RESIDENTIAL PROJECTS
  • EXHIBITION DESIGN
  • MUSEUM / GALLERY SPACES
  • DESIGN / BUILD
  • SCULPTURE + DRAWING
  • WRITING
  • PRESS + PUBLICATIONS
  • RESUMÉ
  • Design with Life
  • Apraxine New York Magazine
  • KELP!
  • salle project info
  • Idea as Model
  • Musée Imaginaire
  • Playtime
  • ruins revisited
  • Building on the Ruins
  • New School CRW
  • Pratt Anthropocene Seminar
  • Menu

CHRISTIAN HUBERT STUDIO

  • RESIDENTIAL PROJECTS
  • EXHIBITION DESIGN
  • MUSEUM / GALLERY SPACES
  • DESIGN / BUILD
  • SCULPTURE + DRAWING
  • WRITING
  • PRESS + PUBLICATIONS
  • RESUMÉ
  • Design with Life
  • Apraxine New York Magazine
  • KELP!
  • salle project info
  • Idea as Model
  • Musée Imaginaire
  • Playtime
  • ruins revisited
  • Building on the Ruins
  • New School CRW
  • Pratt Anthropocene Seminar

contact:

info@christianhubert.com

Greenland without Ice

Greenland without Ice

Climate Change

February 13, 2022

Among legitimate scientists, there is an overwhelming consensus on the reality of climate change. Virtually all professional climate scientists agree on the reality of human-induced climate change, but debate continues on tempo and mode.

The world is "neither prepared to slow down climate change, nor to live with it." climate change is the emblematic problem of the Anthropocene: it is both a driver and a symbol of a thoroughly transformed world. Anthropogenic climate change is primarily a consequence of burning fossil fuels and deforestation.

In the conditions of the Anthropocene, many natural disasters have become “unnatural”ones. The conditions for the recent fires in Maui, for example, were established through record sea-surface temperatures, rising sea levels, and the loss of coastal wetlands. A sharp uptick in warming in just the past decade has made the state more fire-prone and, at the same time, it has fostered the spread of the sorts of plants that provide wildfires with fuel.

Global warming causes climate change. "Warming of the climate system is unequivocal, as is now evident from observations of increases in global average air and ocean temperatures, widespread melting of snow and ice, and rising global average sea level." from IPCC, 2007: Summary for policymakers. Every single year of this century (2001-2008) has been among the top ten warmest years since instrumental records began.

Some of the major effects of warming are loss of sea ice, melting of permafrost, heatwaves and drought, frequency of wildfires (including wildfires in the tundra) -- which put more CO2 into the atmosphere and retard further absorption by plants -- reductions in food crops, hotter summers, changes in precipitation as storm systems move towards poles (leading to increases towards the poles, reductions in Mediterranean, SW North America, Southern Africa), ocean acidification, and eventually sea level rise, which will continue for centuries. Sea levels rise in a warming world for several distinct reasons: One is simple thermal expansion of ocean water (steric effects). Another is melting glaciers, and a third is the contribution from the melting of the gigantic ice sheets on Greenland and Antarctica.

Changes in the atmospheric abundance of greenhouse gases (carbon dioxide, methane, and nitrous oxide) and aerosols, as well as changes in solar radiation and in land surface properties alter the energy balance of the climate system. These changes are expressed in terms of radiative forcing, which is a measure of the influence that a factor has in altering the balance of incoming and outgoing energy in the Earth-atmosphere system.

"Most of the observed increase in globally averaged temperatures since the mid-20th century is very likely due to the observed increase in anthropogenic greenhouse gas concentrations" (IPCC 2007.) ("very likely" means at least 90% probable.)

The precise wording of these statements are a result of lengthy discussion between scientists and government representatives. The IPCC is both governmental and scientific. It was created not to foster new research but to compile and assess existing knowledge on a politically charged issue. Climate science does not tell us what policies to pursue, but it does identify the problems, explain why they matter, and give society insights that can help to frame efficacious policy responses.

The basic framework for treaties on Climate Change is the UNFCCC, the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change, which was negotiated at the "earth summit" in Rio de Janiero in 1992. Its objective was to "stabilize greenhouse gas concentration in the atmosphere at a level that would prevent dangerous anthropogenic interference with the climate system". The framework set out to publish emissions information, control emissions, publish information of policies, compensate developing countries for the cost of compliance, and to transfer technologies.

As their habitats shrink and overlap, grizzlies and polar bears have started to mate, creating new hybrids: pizzlies or grolars.

As their habitats shrink and overlap, grizzlies and polar bears have started to mate, creating new hybrids: pizzlies or grolars.

The science of climate change is a complex system science and never "settled". Nonetheless, there are well-established components, as well as competing explanations and speculative components. Such a science does not work on falsification, but on preponderance of evidence. "you don't need to have every component of a problem deeply understood to practice risk management." (Steven Schneider) This confidence is "long term and global", not "short scale and local", although the most important aspects of climate change are local, not global, and are not confined to warming. The increasing awareness of rapid climate change has reduced the difference between historical time and geological time.

The science of climate change does not provide opportunities for experiment, or at least deliberate and controlled experiment — aside from humanity’s “great geophysical experiment” of increasing carbon dioxide in the atmosphere. (the quote is from Roger Revelle and Hans Seuss)

The science attempts to provide information about risk. The policies need to address risk management. (one important tenet of risk management is diversification. Flexibility is another.) There are reasonable differences of opinion of how best to respond to climate change and even how serious global warming is relative to other environmental and social issues. (Oreskes) Advocacy groups (who represent a political point of view) and media (who try to portray "balance") have different responsibilities from scientists, who consider the relative probabilities of multiple outcomes. But another question remains as well: How can we justify using science to inform policy, if the science might be wrong? (one example might be the difficulties of establishing local consequences of climate change, which are the ones that would be politically relevant) One way to address that question is to ask what evidence we have, or what other possible hypotheses could be correct.

“Climate change is a global collective action problem since all of us face the likelihood of extremely adverse outcomes that could be reduced if many participants take expensive actions.” (Elinor Ostrom) “Collective action” refers to settings where costly actions are made independently, but outcomes jointly affect everyone involved. The conventional theory predicts, for example, that no one will reduce emissions without externally imposed regulations at the global scale.

The most challenging scientific task of all is to build a common international framework for Earth System science that can harness the potential synergies that will arise from the interactions of tens of thousands of investigators, research groups and institutions around the world. The ultimate challenge, however, is directed towards the governance and management communities, as they must deal with the implications of Earth System science. How can a large group of independent nations with differing cultures, values, wealth, social organization and world views come together to manage their own single, connected life support system in a coherent and effective way? One possible strategy is polycentrism.

Extreme weather events like "Superstorm" Sandy (a hurricane that merged with with a mid-latitude weather system to form a hybrid storm) have elements of natural variability and elements of climate change. Aspects of climate change favor the odds of a stronger hurricane. Hurricanes form over warm sea surface, and surface temperatures of oceans are higher. The atmosphere is more moist, with more potential for rainfall. Storm surges during Sandy were higher because sea level is higher -- due to thermal expansion of sea water as it warms, and melting of land-based ice. While IPCC estimates are in the 18-59 cm rise by the end of the twenty-first century, a global rise of 1 meter is a plausible scenario if the Greenland and/or Antarctic ice sheets become significant sources or sea-level rise.

after sandy.jpg

Climate change is also a problem about development, about access to energy, protecting poor and rural communities...(see below)

Climate refugees in Ethiopia, which has been experiencing historic droughts, that have led to water scarcity and food insecurity for millions.

Climate refugees in Ethiopia, which has been experiencing historic droughts, that have led to water scarcity and food insecurity for millions.

In Late Victorian Holocausts Mike Davis explores the relation between climate and social critique. His basic argiument is unequivocal: the succession of devastating famines and the enduring economic marginalization of the agrarian monsoonal regions they set in train cannot be explained by either the critique of capitalism or by climatology alone. To grasp the concept of ‘the making of the Third World’ requires a fusion of critical social analysis and the geoscientific understanding of the nonlinear dynamics of the earth system.

The great challenge of the twenty-first century is to slow down climate change as much as possible. There is too much inertia in the system to stop climate change anytime soon. As the Earth’s resources become scarcer, wars and conflicts over resources seem inevitable. Today, Russia’s war on Ukraine is financed by its income from sales of hydrocarbons (oil and gas). This is a dire example of the “geohistory” that combines human history and earth history that Dipesh Chakrabarty called for. The historian Timothy Snyder calls the rulers of Russia a “hydrocarbon oligarchy”. (see his expanded version of On Tyranny.) Snyder describes the “politics of catastrophe” as a warning that “the future is coming for you.”

Prev / Next

WRITINGS

This hypertext document is a dictionary of concepts deriving from two main sources: The first is the literature of criticism, literary studies, and the humanities. The second is the literature of science, and contemporary interpretations of the sciences.

My primary interest is to explore the borrowings and polyvalent meanings of specific terms – in order to map out some of the convergences, overlaps, shifting perspectives, and outright conflicts between contemporary criticism and the sciences.

The content list below is organized accordingly. The first major heading is Theory, and the second is Technoscience.

Christian Hubert, August 2019


  • abstraction
  • aesthetics
  • art history
  • biological
  • body
  • complexity
  • computation
  • conceptual
  • culture
  • D + G
  • desire
  • dynamics
  • evolution
  • Foucault
  • local / global
  • machinic
  • memory
  • metaphor
  • modernity
  • order / disorder
  • political
  • power
  • psychological
  • representation
  • simulation
  • social
  • spatial
  • subject
  • symbolic
  • technology
  • time
  • visuality

Content List

WRITING front page

THEORY

Aesthetic

Critique of Judgement

Empathy

Form / Matter

Form

Gestalt

Formalism

Formless

Frame

Genius

Ornament

Style

Assemblage

Bachelor Machine

Diagram / Abstract

Machine

Machinic Phylum

Body 

Body image

Body thinking

BwO

Embodiment

Incorporating practices

Clothing / garment

phantom limb

Prosthesis

Limbs

Clinamen

Fold

Culture

Danger

Ethnicity

Fetish

Myth

nature / culture

Popular culture

Primitive

Ritual

Taboo

Desire

Affect

Desiring machines

Eroticism

Distinctions

Abstract / Concrete

aggregate / systematic

analytic / synthetic

Being / becoming

Continuity / discontinuity

Homogeneity / heteroge

Imaginary / symbolic

mind / brain

Qualitative / Quantitative

Strategy / Tactics

Surface / Depth

Transcend / Immanence

Globalization

Glocal

Local / global 

Economic

commodity

Ethics

Climate Justice

History

Critical history

Instrumentality

Praxis

Genealogy

Hermeneutics

Ideology

Social construction

Idea

 Ideal / real

Image

Imagination

Language

Allegory

Metaphor / Model

Narrative

Memory

Modernism

Avant-garde

Postmodernism

Nature

Nature / Culture

Pain 

Panic

Phantom limbs

Pharmakos

Death

Perception

Perceptual / Conceptual

Place

Aporia

Place / identity

Non-place

Aleatory

Play

Pleasure

Political

Power

Authoritarianism

Biopower

Control

Discipline

Discourse

Hegemony

Surveillance

Representation

Mirror

Sexuality

Phallus

Sex / Gender

Subject

Agency

Ego

Superego

Will

Alterity / other

Anxiety

Identity

identity politics

Ressentiment

Intersubjectivity

Love

Narcissism

Repression

Return of the repressed

Schismogenesis

Schizophrenia

Sublimation

Unconscious

Symbol

Ruin

Thinking

Truth

Wonder

Intuition

Intentionality

Quodlibet

Visuality

Visible / Articulable

Visible / Intelligible

Spectacle

Work

Writing





PHILOS/POLIT/ECO

Anthropocene

anthropocenic

Consumerism

consumer / citizen

consumerism

Enclosure

Copyright

Monopoly

Sustainability

sustainable development


TECHNOSCIENCE

A-Life 

Cellular Automata

Anthropic Principle

Anthropocene

Artifacts

Automaton

Automobile

Clock

Cyborg

orrery

Railway

Titanic

Brain

Mind / Brain

consciousness

Anosognosia

Aphasia

Attention

Neuron

Reentry

Complexity

Autocatalysis

Autopoesis

catastrophe

Dissipative structures

Emergence

Self-organization

Computation

Cyberscience

Cybernetics

Cyberspace

Cuber(t)

Genetic algorithms

Distinctions

Closed / Open systems

Explain / Describe

Mechanism / Vitalism

Mitosis / Meiosis

Order / disorder

Dirt

Parallel / Serial

Population / Typological

Logical type

Prokaryote / Eucaryote

Top down / Bottom up

Dynamics

Attractors

Basin of Attraction

Bifurcation

B/Z reaction

Chaos

Energy

Entropy

Entropy: interpretations

Ergodic

Non-linearity

Phase Space

Phase beauty

Sensitivity to initial

Singularity

Evolution

Adaptation

Coevolution

Epigenesis/Preformation

Exaptation

Fitness Landscape

Natural selection

Species

Teleology

Field

Force

Gaia

Geometry

Dimension

Fractals

Mandlebrot set

Hypertext

Hypertext City

Intelligent building

Network

Transclusion

Immune system

Antibodies

T-cells, B-cells

Mapping

Morphology

Analogy / homology

Embryo

Induction

Morphogenesis

Positional information

Morphic fields

Neoteny

Natural Form

Organicism

Phyllotaxis

Unity

Organism

Character

Paradigm

Path dependency

Randomness

Replication

Resonance

Science

Big Science

Art / Science

Science / Philosophy

Simulation

Simulacrum

Space

Art historical

Heimlich / Unheimlich

Inside / outside

Pack donkey / man

Personal space

Psycho-sexual space

Sacred / profane

Scientific space

Social space

Space / Place

Space vs Time 

Textual space

Topos

Symbiosis

Synergetics

Time

Biological time

Dureé

Event

Real time

Procrastination

Time and technology

Tech History

Electronic media

Printing

Tech metaphor

Tech philosophy

Virtual

Consensual hallucin…

Immersion

Virtual reality

Vision

Eye movement

Field of Vision

War

Peace